Electric Smokers vs Pellet Smokers: An In-Depth Comparison

This article has links to products that we may make commission from.

When it comes to selecting the ideal grill, people who enjoy cooking outdoors frequently find themselves confronted with a difficult option. In recent years, electric and pellet smokers have emerged as two of the most popular types of grills available on the market. So which one is better and which one should you buy for the best smoking experience?

In this detailed guide, we’ll provide you with an in-depth comparison of electric smokers vs pellet smokers, focusing on their most important characteristics, as well as the benefits and drawbacks of each option and other important considerations that will help you make an educated choice.

Electric smokers vs pellet smokers an in depth comparison for your grilling needs

🥧 If you’re interested in more great recipes, I share all my favorite recipes at A Food Lover’s KitchenInstant Pot recipes over at A Pressure Cooker Kitchen, air fryer recipes at Air Fry Anytime, and cocktails and drinks at Savored Sips. Check it out today!

Understanding Electric Smokers

Electric smokers are a type of grilling appliance that derive the majority of their heat from an electric element. Typically, they have a heating element, a water pan, a tray for holding wood chips, and racks for cooking food.

The wood chips catch fire and emit smoke as a result of the heat generated by the heating element, which in turn causes the heat to be generated. This smoke is then used to cook the meal, which imparts its taste into the dish.

Understanding Pellet Smokers

Pellet smokers, on the other hand, make use of pellets of compressed wood as their primary source of fuel. These barbecues have an auger system that moves wood pellets from a storage hopper into a firepot, where a hot rod lights them on fire. The pellets are then used to cook food.

The heat and smoke that are produced are then distributed evenly throughout the cooking chamber, which allows the food to be cooked while imparting a smoky flavor to it.

How to use a pellet grill

Pros and Cons

Electric Smokers


  • Electric smokers are user-friendly because their operation is as easy as plugging them in and letting them run, making them ideal for beginners.
  • Temperature is constant. These smokers keep the temperature at which they cook at a constant level during the whole duration of cooking, which guarantees even cooking.
  • Electric smokers have lower operational costs than traditional ones do since the cost of the fuel, electricity, is generally less expensive than the cost of other fuels.
  • It can be used indoors. Electric smokers can be brought inside, giving you more options for where you may do your cooking.


  • When compared to other kinds of grills, electric smokers may generate a smokey flavor that isn’t as strong as that produced by other kinds of barbecues.
  • Because these smokers need to be plugged into a power source, their portability, and usefulness are restricted when the power is out.
  • Electric smokers often have a maximum temperature that is lower than that of other types of grills because of their limited temperature range.

Pellet Smokers


  • When compared to electric smokers, pellet smokers offer a flavor that is both more authentic and intensely smokey.
  • Because these grills have a larger temperature range, you may use them for a variety of cooking methods, including smoking, grilling, and baking.
  • With modern digital controllers, pellet smokers provide great temperature control for consistent results.
  • Customers can choose from a variety of kinds of wood pellets to achieve a wide range of flavor profiles.


  • A large initial investment is required due to the fact that pellet smokers are often more costly than electric smokers.
  • Pellet smokers are limited in their portability due to their need on energy since, despite the fact that they burn wood pellets as fuel, the auger and fan systems in pellet smokers require electricity to function.
  • Wood pellets may be more expensive than electricity, which adds to the overall expense of running the business because of the higher fuel cost.
Smoker with short ribs

Flavor Comparison

The flavor provided by pellet smokers is unquestionably superior to that produced by electric smokers. A more genuine and robustly smoky flavor may be achieved through the use of wood pellets in pellet grills.

This flavor is very similar to the flavor that can be achieved with traditional wood or charcoal grills. Users are able to experiment with a range of flavor profiles thanks to the availability of a wide selection of wood pellet flavors in pellet smokers. Some examples of these flavors are hickory, apple, cherry, and mesquite.

When opposed to pellet grills, electric smokers typically produce a flavor that is less robust but is still able to lend a smokey taste to the food that is being smoked.

Those who want a more strong, smoky flavor may find that the flavor that is provided by electric smokers does not satisfy them to the same degree. Yet, electric smokers are still capable of producing delectable results, particularly for people who want a less overpowering taste of smoked flavor.

What Smokers We Use

Z grills

Z Grills 7002C2E Pellet Grill & Smoker

We use the 7002C2E, which has dual temperature probes, a huge pellet hopper and pellet viewing window, with a large grill space and streamlined design. See this grill and more on the Z Grills site.

Q? Encoding=utf8&asin=b07glk1nc2&format= sl250 &id=asinimage&marketplace=us&serviceversion=20070822&ws=1&tag=legendsofthegrill 20&language=en us

Traeger Grills Pro Series 22 Pellet Grill & Smoker

Did you know that Traeger created the original wood-pellet grill? The Pro Series 22 is the one most people choose because it’s compact, yet has plenty of space for cooking. You can use any type of wood pellets you like. See the Traeger Series 22 Grill on Amazon.

Capacity to Regulate Temperature

Both pellet and electric smokers have excellent temperature control capabilities. Electric smokers are capable of preserving a constant temperature throughout the duration of the cooking process, which is an essential factor in producing evenly cooked food.

The majority of electric smokers come with an internal thermostat, which makes it simple to control and keep the temperature at the level you want it to be.

Pellet smokers, on the other hand, frequently come equipped with sophisticated digital controllers that make it possible for users to set and maintain temperatures within a narrow range. It is possible for high-quality pellet grills to keep temperature changes within a range of +/- 5 degrees Fahrenheit, which ensures that the outcomes are always the same.

Smoker grill combo

Assessing Temperature Range

Pellet smokers, in comparison to electric smokers, typically provide a wider temperature range, which makes them more flexible for use with a variety of cooking methods. Users are able to smoke, grill, and even bake using the same equipment because a high-quality pellet smoker can achieve temperatures ranging from 180 degrees Fahrenheit to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

Electric smokers, on the other hand, typically have a temperature range that is more constrained, frequently reaching a maximum of somewhere between 275 and 300 degrees Fahrenheit.

This temperature range is suitable for most smoking endeavors; but, high-heat grilling and baking are probably not the best uses for it.

Ease of Cleaning and Maintenance

Electric smokers are simple to clean and maintain. Their basic design has fewer moving components, which reduces the possibility of mechanical faults. Users must remove and clean the cooking racks, water pan, and wood chip tray while cleaning an electric smoker. In addition, the interior should be washed down on a regular basis to remove any buildup.

While not unduly sophisticated, pellet smokers may require more care than electric smokers due to their auger system, firepot, and other components. Cleaning the cooking grates, grease management system, and firepot, as well as removing the ash from the firebox, are all routine maintenance activities.

To guarantee the longevity and best functioning of the pellet smoker, it is critical to follow the manufacturer’s cleaning and maintenance requirements.

Cleaning out the smoker

Cost Analysis

Upfront Expenses

Pellet smokers have a higher upfront cost than electric smokers. Depending on the features and build quality, high-grade pellet grills can cost anywhere from a few hundred to several thousand dollars. Electric smokers, on the other hand, are often more economical, with a large range of alternatives available at various price points.

Operating Costs

Electric smokers have lower operating costs because energy is usually less expensive than wood pellets. However, keep in mind that the cost of electricity varies based on your region and energy supplier.

Pellet smokers have greater fuel expenses due to the need for wood pellets, yet providing exceptional flavor and adaptability. Also, because of their digital controllers and other electrical components, some pellet grills may require more electricity.

Choosing the Best Grill for You

The decision between an electric and a pellet smoker is influenced by personal preferences, budget, and cooking requirements. Electric smokers are ideal for novices and people who prefer a simpler, lower-maintenance solution with consistent results. They are also suitable for people who have limited space or who prefer to use their smoker indoors.

Pellet smokers are ideal for individuals who want a more realistic and robust smoky flavor and value the versatility of using multiple cooking styles with a single device. They are suitable for outdoor cooking lovers who are willing to pay a greater initial cost as well as continuous fuel costs in exchange for the benefits of improved flavor and performance.

Smoker with food

Final Thoughts

Personal tastes, price, and cooking requirements all play a role in deciding between an electric smoker and a pellet smoker. Electric smokers provide simplicity, affordability, and ease of use, making them a perfect choice for those who are new to smoking or prefer low-maintenance cooking.

Pellet smokers, on the other hand, cater to more experienced grillers or those who desire true smoky flavors by providing adaptability, a greater flavor profile, and precise temperature control.

You may make an informed decision and choose the grill that best meets your needs and preferences by carefully evaluating the variables described in this thorough guide, such as advantages and cons, flavor influence, temperature control, and range, ease of cleaning and maintenance, and pricing.

Like this recipe? We’d love for you to share it on your Pinterest board! Click to follow our Pinterest boards so you can find all our recipes! 

Instagram it! If you try this recipe please tag #legendsofthegrill on Instagram or Twitter. We love to see your photos of our recipes! Also follow us on Facebook to keep up on what we’re cooking up.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *